top of page

The journeys we don’t see

Writer: Sandra Witzel
Sandra Witzel
Nov 13
6 min read

Why we need to count the journeys that never happen

Last week I chaired three sessions at three conferences: on cycling and walking, on women’s public transport safety, and on automated vehicles. Each covered lots of ground, but all three spoke of journeys people want to make, but don’t.

One-size-fits-all really means one-size-only-fits-some. Sometimes the vehicle, the infrastructure or the technology doesn’t work for people. Sometimes the journey doesn’t feel safe or isn’t. Those journeys never appear in the figures, so plans built only on this data keep missing them. The people not making those journeys are the ones who can explain what stops them. So they need to be involved, right from the start.

Journeys missing riders

On Tuesday, I was in Bradford for Active Travel Innovations, a conference about delivering safe and attractive walking and cycling schemes. My panel, “No-one left out or behind”, looked at how to get more people from under-represented groups on the move.

Bradford is doing an incredible job here. The council’s Active Travel Social Prescribing pilot, funded by Active Travel England, refers women to cycling and walking sessions run by Hop On. Hop On is a female-led social enterprise, started more than ten years ago by a small group of South Asian women who wanted to learn to ride. It has since supported more than 5,000 people who might never have used a cycle.

Sofia Mushtaq from Bradford Council and Fozia Naseem, Hop On’s co-founder, summed up their approach: “infrastructure creates opportunity, support creates participation”. In Huddersfield, Beth Lomas from Environmental Projects in Kirklees (EPIKS) found that 78% of people surveyed want to cycle more. The EPIKS community engagement programme, run through in-person events and online, showed that simple videos of filmed routes and mapped journey information gave riders confidence to venture out.

The appetite to cycle is there, but appetite alone does not get people on a bike. Infrastructure matters and so do confidence, clear information and practical support. Hop On and EPIKS both started with the communities they serve and built their offer around them. They went to where people already are, rather than building a cycle lane and waiting for them to turn up. These are great examples on how the missing journeys become found.

Journeys that are unsafe

On Wednesday, Planning for Women and Girls, also in Bradford, looked at designing public spaces and transport that are safe for women and girls. Women in Mobility UK (WiM UK), the charity I co-founded, supported the conference. My panel, “Report, respond, protect”, looked at reducing violence and intimidation against women and girls on public transport. We also asked what happens when women report it and whether that leads to action.

The WiM UK team at the Planning for Women & Girls Conference
The WiM UK team at the Planning for Women & Girls Conference

Girlguiding’s 2025 Girls’ Attitudes Survey found that 56% of girls and young women aged 11 to 21 feel unsafe on public transport when alone. None of the journeys they avoid, as a result, turn up in a passenger count. Much of the safety advice they receive asks them to adapt: take another route, wear something else, don’t travel alone at night. Girlguiding’s report says girls want others’ behaviours to change rather than carrying the burden themselves.

Harassment is also largely invisible in the data. Nia Mellor from British Transport Police (BTP) presented research on reporting harassment on the railway. 57% of people had no faith anything would happen and many didn’t know how to report it.

The Greater Manchester team showed what changes when organisations tackle this together. Kate Green from Transport for Greater Manchester (TfGM) and Neil Humphreys from Greater Manchester Police (GMP) explained how transport and policing now work side by side. When TfGM asked women what would help, more security and safety staff came top of the list, followed by safer bus stops.

Their TravelSafe LiveChat, built into the Bee Network, Greater Manchester’s public transport network, gives passengers a simple way to report what happens on their journey. It has handled more than 2,000 messages since launch and 85% led to a police incident log in September 2026. For the authorities, each message is another data point and a chance to respond.

Jocelyn Elleby presented GS-SABR (Smart Automated Behaviour Recognition), a start-up developing artificial intelligence (AI) that detects harassment on buses as it happens. That allows a real-time response and a more accurate picture of incidents that are never reported.

Its value will depend on how well it supports the people who respond, from control room staff to the police. Having worked in technology for much of my career, I would also want AI risks managed from the start: false alarms, missed incidents, bias in who gets flagged, and questions about privacy and data. They need the same governance as any other operational risk. For example, clear accountability lines, regular checks on accuracy and fairness, and rules on what data is kept and for how long.

Two points about language stood out for me. I was glad to learn that BTP now uses Violence and Intimidation Against Women and Girls (VIAWG), not only Violence Against Women and Girls (VAWG). That brings in behaviour that may otherwise never be reported as a crime, such as being followed or stared at.

Michael Conroy, founder of Men at Work, asked: “Where’s the M in VAWG?” The current term names who is harmed, but not who causes the harm. I think that’s a fair challenge and one Men at Work takes on by supporting the safe, healthy and empathetic development of boys and young men.

What I took from the session is that if we continue to expect women to adapt, we are accepting that those journeys stay lost. Organisations must carry more of that burden, through visible staff, simple reporting that leads to action and well-governed technology. They must also involve women more in shaping those services, right from the start.

Journeys we can still design

On Thursday, I was in York for the Local Transport Summit, which brings together local and national transport decision-makers. My panel, “CAVs: beyond the tech”, looked at the questions about connected and automated vehicles (CAVs) that go beyond the technology.

Rebecca Posner from Wayfinder Research showed research in which members of the public designed their own automated vehicle. They were designed for need, with room for wheelchairs and journeys to hospitals at night. Adrian Ulisse from Uber pointed out that health transport is a gap Uber is already stepping into, so there’s an existing opportunity. Rebecca also distinguished between acceptance, where people are asked to trust a system anyway, and acceptability, where the system has to earn that trust. Personal safety shows why that matters: take the driver out and you remove someone who can make a journey feel safer.

Lawrence Penn from Steer outlined the levers local authorities hold. Under the Automated Vehicles Act 2024, a driverless taxi-style service needs consent from each licensing authority it will operate in. A bus-style service in a franchised area needs consent from the franchising authority. Authorities have six weeks to respond. If they don’t respond, or refuse without giving written reasons, consent is assumed.

What I took from the session is that there is still time to design the missing journeys in. But six weeks doesn’t seem like enough time for comprehensive co-design with the community. That conversation needs to start well before a request arrives.

Time to start counting what we don’t see

What we measure has a big influence on what we build. Count boardings and you plan for the people already boarding. Count recorded crime and a rise in reports looks like failure, while the woman who quietly stops travelling doesn’t register at all.

Audit and risk work has taught me to be wary of quiet. A clean report can mean things are going well. Or it can mean nobody is looking in the right place. In transport, low complaints and steady passenger numbers can hide people who have given up on a journey.

Nobody should have to plan their journey around fear or around a system never designed with them in mind. Every transport plan, infrastructure project and new technology rests on assumptions about who will use it. Before any of them is signed off, it is worth asking whose journeys those assumptions leave out.


With thanks to Landor LINKS and to my panellists: Nic Cook, Sofia Mushtaq, Fozia Naseem, Kate Ball, Simon Bowkett and Beth Lomas at Active Travel Innovations; Kate Green, Neil Humphreys, Nia Mellor, Owen Cotterell and Jocelyn Elleby at Planning for Women and Girls; and Rebecca Posner, Lawrence Penn and Adrian Ulisse at the Local Transport Summit.


Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page